Free shipping on purchases over $65

Original Plymouth
Original Plymouth
Original Plymouth
Original Plymouth
Original Plymouth
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Original Plymouth
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Original Plymouth
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Original Plymouth
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Original Plymouth
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Original Plymouth

Original Plymouth

CHEDDAR AGED 1 YEAR | RAW COW MILK | 8 OZ. WAXED BLOCK
This original Coolidge family formula was discovered by Jesse Werner on a frayed scrap of paper, taped to the walls of the old Plymouth factory. Aged for one whole year, this is a full-bodied cheese, rounded with the perfect balance of cream and tang. It’s the most historic of the English varieties — an old-world recipe with a sharp, rich flavor profile that lingers, like a passed down story — and said to be closest to what the settlers of the 1600s enjoyed. As the great forebearer of the whole Plymouth line, this raw heritage cheddar literally tastes like a walk back in time.
$13.00
$13.00
Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Growth Hormone Free
100% Raw Milk
Gluten
Free
Questions? Contact Us

Flavor Profile

Sharp and Rich

Specs

8 oz. waxed cheese block, made with raw cow milk that is single-sourced from a dedicated herd of Holstein and Jersey cows.

Customer Reviews
4.7 Based on 15 Reviews
5 ★
93% 
14
4 ★
0% 
0
3 ★
0% 
0
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
7% 
1
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
TD
08/01/2023
Thomas d.
United States United States

We love this cheese:

My family has been buying this cheddar since the 1950s. There's nothing else quite like it. So glad I can have it shipped to California!!! Thanks for making this delicious treat!!

Original Plymouth
Share   |   Facebook  •  Twitter
Was this helpful?  0    0
SM
03/22/2023
Shirley M.
United States United States

Love it

Super smooth cheese.

Original Plymouth
Share   |   Facebook  •  Twitter
Was this helpful?  0    0
TD
03/01/2023
Thomas d.
United States United States

a lifetime favorite!

I first had this cheese in the 1950s when my family would visit Plymouth every year. Then, we boarded by the wheel and with the family of eight, we work our way right through it. Now I'm in California, so I have them ship half a dozen blocks to me and my wife and I enjoy it so much! Great cheese, unlike any other chatter I have ever had!

Original Plymouth
Share   |   Facebook  •  Twitter
Was this helpful?  0    0
JG
02/28/2023
Jackie G.
United States United States

Best cheese,

The black truffle is my favorite! I recommend trying it! The flaorus delicious!

Original Plymouth
Share   |   Facebook  •  Twitter
Was this helpful?  0    1
TP
11/11/2022
Tom P.
United States United States

Best cheese for grilled cheese sandwiches ever.

When I was a kid, my grandmother used this cheese to make the best grilled cheese sandwiches ever. It took me 40 years to find it, though, because I could not remember the name. I only knew it was something she ordered special from Vermont. A recent online search listed this cheese and the name immediately refreshed a distant memory.

Original Plymouth
Share   |   Facebook  •  Twitter
Was this helpful?  1    0